Vocational Experts
Vocational experts evaluate what work an injured person can still do. Where they appear in a Texas workers' comp claim, who hires them, and how their reports can help you or be used against your benefits.
What a vocational expert is
A vocational expert is a specialist in work itself: what a job physically requires, which skills carry over from one occupation to another, and what jobs actually exist in a labor market. In a workers' comp claim, everything a vocational expert produces answers some version of one question: what work can this person still do, given these restrictions, this education, and this experience?
That question sounds neutral. Whether the answer helps you or hurts you depends almost entirely on who hired the expert. Vocational experts appear in a Texas claim in three distinct roles, and the difference between them is the point of this page.
The state's version: vocational rehabilitation
The Texas Workforce Commission runs Vocational Rehabilitation Services, a state program that helps people with injuries and disabilities return to work through counseling, retraining, education, and job placement. The service costs the worker nothing, and the Division of Workers' Compensation (DWC, the state agency that oversees comp claims) refers injured workers to it.
For one group of workers this program carries direct benefit consequences. Workers receiving supplemental income benefits, called SIBs, must make a qualifying work-search effort every quarter, and participation in a vocational rehabilitation program through the Texas Workforce Commission or an approved private provider is one of the recognized ways to qualify. Vocational Rehabilitative Services in SIBs Cases covers how that path works, and Supplemental Income Benefits (SIBs) in Texas Workers' Compensation Claims explains the benefit itself.
The carrier's version: return-to-work services
The insurance carrier (the company paying benefits on your claim) may hire its own vocational counselor and offer you return-to-work services: resume help, job leads, sometimes retraining suggestions. Some of this help is genuine. None of it is neutral. The carrier pays for these services because moving you back into work, on paper or in fact, reduces what it owes.
Treat a carrier vocational counselor the way you would treat any carrier representative. Be truthful, be accurate about your restrictions, and understand that your level of cooperation is being documented. Declining to engage can itself become a report. If a carrier vocational counselor has contacted you, tell your attorney if you have one, and answer in writing where you can.
The dispute version: the expert witness
When money is in dispute, vocational experts appear as expert witnesses, and this is where their reports do the most damage. Two reports are standard. A transferable skills analysis lists the kinds of work the expert says your background qualifies you for. A labor market survey lists specific jobs the expert says exist within your restrictions, often with employer names and wage figures.
Carriers use these reports mainly in two fights. In SIBs disputes, a labor market survey is offered to show that work you could do existed while you searched, an argument covered at Failure to Seek Employment (SIBs Cases). In lifetime income benefits disputes, employability reports are offered to show a worker can still perform some gainful work; Lifetime Income Benefits (LIBs) in Texas Workers' Compensation Claims explains what is at stake there.
A vocational report is opinion evidence, and it can be answered. The strongest answer to a theoretical list of jobs is a documented record of real applications and real outcomes. A worker who applied to the very kinds of jobs the survey lists, and was not hired, has turned the carrier's own report into support for the claim. Proving Your SIBs Job Searches explains how to build that record.
Whose side the expert is on
The answer is unglamorous: the side that hired them. A Texas Workforce Commission counselor works for a state program whose goal is your reemployment. A carrier-retained expert works for the carrier. Workers and their attorneys can retain vocational experts too, and in serious disputes over lifetime benefits, they do. Read every vocational report with the hiring party in mind, and check what the expert actually knew: reports built without a current medical picture, or without your real work history, are built to be challenged.
Contact Us
